Russian Eurovision – Mamo song creates controversy

In a move sure to delight conspiracy theorists and bloggers everywhere, Mamu by Anastasia Prikhodko was picked to represent Russia at this year’s Eurovision.

The controversy?  Well, Prikhodko is Ukrainian, and Mamo is sung partly in Russian and partly in – gasp – Ukrainian. Oh yes, and Prikhodko only entered the Russian qualification contest after she’d been kicked out of the Ukrainian qualification contest.

The biggest complaints about Prikhodko’s victory came, not too surprisingly, from Yusif Prigozhin the husband of the singer who finished second.

“It’s a disgrace… A song performed in Ukrainian can’t have anything to do with Russia.”

Given that his wife’s song (along with most of the other contestants’) was sung in English, so I’m not entirely sure how he came to this conculsion.

Anyways, personally I think it’s a bit of a coup for Russia.  They not only get to put one over arch enemies Georgia, who have entered a grumpy song about how they don’t like Putin – they get to claim that in Russia, music is all about peace and goodwill between neighbours.  Oh, and that they like Ukrainians, really.

And, actually, I think the song’s ok – it’s not great, but Russia certainly won’t be disgraced in May.

PS – you can see the full history of Russia’s Eurovision experience here – Every Russian Eurovision VIdeo, Ever.

You may also like...

12 Responses

  1. You forgot to add that the music was written by Meladze (Georgian living in Russia) and the lyrics – by an Estonian lady 🙂

    Dmitri Minaev´s last blog post..March 10 in Russian history. Stoletov’s research of photoelectric effect

  2. Andy says:

    You’re right. Russia is being culturally colonised… 🙂

    Andy´s last blog post..“We don’t wanna put in” – Georgia’s Eurovision video

  3. I’d rather put it another way: we’re still one nation 🙂

    Dmitri Minaev´s last blog post..March 10 in Russian history. Stoletov’s research of photoelectric effect

  4. The multiethnic dynamic vis-a-vis Russia has been evident for some time.

    Michael Averko´s last blog post..EPA Strengthens Agenda March 2009

  5. Russia has a crappy song for the second time in a row in Eurovision…oh well, at least its marginally better than in 2008.

    Da Russophile´s last blog post..Translation: Confessions of a Russian “Liberal” Part 2

  6. Alec L says:

    I didn’t like the song at first, since Prikhodko doesn’t have the classic diva pipes and her voice seemed weak. But she really knows how to wield it, and it’s clear by the end she can really put some passion into a performance.
    As far as the Ukrainian bit, I wish both sides would stop pretending that Ukraine and Russia aren’t two sides of the same coin culturally. And WTF is with the rule about no politics on squeaky clean Eurovision? We wouldn’t want things to get interesting, after all.

    Alec L´s last blog post..DragonForce lays waste to SPB

  7. Andy:

    Regarding your post, as you might already know, the mentioned Georgian group hasn’t been kicked out. Instead, they’ve been instructed to select another song:

    http://www.rttv.ru/Top_News/2009-03-10/Georgia_s__Putin_song__banned_from_Eurovision.html

    On the matter of Ukraine, Russia and music, here’s a Cossack song that’s sung in Ukrainian, but with photos of Russian Cossacks:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t74er5nTMHo

    In Ukraine, the Cossack population includes some of the more Russia friendly segments of the population.

    I came across these other songs that are sung by Cossacks:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ABBhRp6bn0&feature=related

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5EbwMCxqxCw&feature=related

    Michael Averko´s last blog post..THE GOP.S SHOULD BE CAREFUL ABOUT HIS "" ACCUSATIONS

  1. March 11, 2009

    […] Russian qualification contest after she?d been kicked out of the Ukrainian qualification contest. Mamo – Russian Eurovision Entry courts controversy | Siberian Light __________________ 3 on a bottle is […]

  2. March 12, 2009

    […] own entry is causing controversy now as well, however. Andy of Siberian Light explains: In a move sure to delight conspiracy theorists and bloggers everywhere, Mam[o] by Anastasia […]

  3. March 12, 2009

    […] ???? ? ??????? ?? ?????? ??????? ????????????. ???? ?? Siberian Light ?????????: […]

  4. March 16, 2009

    […] [linguistics], with whom we have two lectures every Saturday, who said it in connection with the outrage the Russian people has shown in regard to the fact that this year’s Russian contri…. Whoever it was that said it, it was good said, and I’ve had it on my tongue for a long time […]

  5. April 17, 2009

    […] dia nampisy fifandirana ihany koa ny hira nampidirin’ny Rosia ankehitriny. Manazava I Andy manoratra ny ny Siberian Light: Ahitan'ny mpahita petrakevitra momba ny tsikombakomba […]